Warburton Bike Park fails beginners and families
/I don't want to sound ungrateful. It's amazing that a rather large mountain bike park is being constructed right across the road from my home in Millgrove, and that I can go and ride it any time I want for free.
In many respects the trail builders and designers have done a great job. There is a lot of beautiful forest to explore. There are plenty of fast, flowing, thrilling trails. There is a great deal of fun and enjoyment to be had in the woods above Warburton. I use it frequently. I enjoy it a lot.
But…
for the amount of planning that went into it, the amount of money spent, the hype built up over years, the once-in-a-generation opportunity to build a marquee trail network in such a beautiful location so close to a city of five-million people, it is hard not to notice some pretty glaring problems, and to question whether those opportunities were fully utilised.
Let me first try and convince you that this isn’t a middle-aged guy having a whinge. Warburton Bike Park actually works pretty well for someone like me; a reasonably fit, reasonably experienced mountain biker. Nor am I trying to naysay. I love mountain biking. I want Warburton Bike Park to succeed. But it will not fulfil its potential without addressing certain issues.
The primary problem I see is the lack of accessibility and safety for certain trail users, specifically beginners, kids and families. This is ironic given how hard Warburton Bike Park seems to be portraying itself, in its own promotional material, as friendly to these groups. The disparity between the messaging and the on-the-ground reality invites cynicism, like all those woke-washing ads for the big banks.
Perhaps it is best to begin illustrating what I mean through the lens of my own family. My son is about to turn six. He likes riding his bike around the neighbourhood and on the rail trail, and he’s at an age where he could start on some mountain bike trails, but despite having the bike park at our doorstep, I don’t know where to take him.
There are no little loops at Warburton Bike Park, no short climbs. There isn’t an up trail that takes me less than about 25 minutes at a moderate pace. A six-year-old would be exhausted before they got half-way, if they could even get that far. The ‘green’ (easy) climbing trail from Warburton, Uptown Flow, whilst moderate in gradient, has a number of tight and steep switchbacks that even I found a bit tricky to negotiate the first several times I rode it, and took some practice to master. There is also a pretty steep drop-off over the side of the trail in many places.
The many switchbacks preclude the use of a tow rope that can run from the back of an adults bike to the handlebars of a kids bike to help them uphill, and a kids electric mountain bike will not be in the family budget for the foreseeable future (sorry kiddo, re-stumping the house gets priority). There is the shuttle service, but at $200 for a half-day for a family of four, it isn’t exactly what many would consider affordable, especially for repeat sessions.
Even if you made it to the top of these ‘shorter’ climbing trails, the green descending trails on the lower part of the park–the Mt Little Joe area–are paradoxically dangerous. To explain why, I’ll need to delve a little into some technical and historical details of mountain biking, but I’ll be as brief as possible.
Mountain biking arose in the 70’s as a carefree, counter-cultural movement with a dirtbag sensibility. It basically consisted of a bunch of unshowered dudes pushing old beach cruiser bikes up a hill and bombing down a fire road.
Before long, purpose-built mountain bikes arrived on the market, and volunteers were scratching purpose-built but informal trails through their local forest, with shovel and pickaxe and perhaps a chainsaw.
And this is how things were for quite a while, through the 80’s and 90’s and into the 2000’s. Because trails were built by hand with volunteer labour, they were generally narrow, janky and ‘technical,’ which basically means rough, featuring rocks, roots and other irregularities arising from the natural terrain. In today’s parlance they would be called ‘tech’ trails.
Mountain bikes from that period were also far less capable than they are now, which meant that riders had to negotiate these trails with a good deal of care and precision. This fostered skill development, judgement and control in a lower speed and therefore a lower consequence environment.
Things are a lot different now. Warburton Bike Park represents the culmination of a number of trends that have played out over the last twenty or so years in mountain biking. More trails are being built professionally, using machines such as mini diggers. Far greater resources are available to design, landscape and groom trails so that they are relatively smooth and fast flowing. These machine-built ‘flow’ trails predominate at Warburton Bike Park, particularly the easy and intermediate trails. They can be a lot of fun, but when they are the first exposure to mountain biking for a beginner, it can increase risk.
The green descending trails at Warburton are easy in the sense that everything is ‘rollable.’ This means that there are no features that require ‘committing’ to, say, a big jump with a gap in the middle, or a steep chute you can’t bail out of. But you can gain speed very quickly, and once you’re going too fast, it can be easy to lose control, and very hard to reign it back in before you’re heading straight for a tree. As many a TAC road safety campaign has told us, speed greatly amplifies the consequences of small mistakes. There’s a reason road speed limits have been dropping all around the state. It takes experience to manage speed safely.
People have always injured themselves mountain biking, but in the past it tended to be more broken wrists and collarbones. Things that hurt, but things that you can recover from and continue living a normal life. I don’t have statistics in front of me, if they even exist, but it is much more common now to hear of broken necks, backs and serious concussions; things that really do change a life.
It is often young men and boys who are sustaining these injuries. Boys who didn’t have the opportunity to build skill on a narrow, rutted bush track, and whose brains don’t yet have the software to calculate risk. They see riders doing crazy things on Red Bull’s social media feed, and they want to copy their heroes. They want their moment of glory. The need for social validation can override everything else. They’re not thinking about the potential of living with pain or decreased mobility for the rest of their life.
As much as I love mountain biking, it is uncomfortable to witness the seeming steady stream of medical evacuations from the slopes of Mt Little Joe, Mt Tugwell and Mt Bride, and to consider how we got here. The environment we are sending these kids into is ultimately a product of decisions made by adults, collectively and over time.
Warburton Bike Park is like an aquatic facility with no toddler pool. No place for little kids to safely dip their toes in, splash around, get used to simply being wet. There is an intermediate pool, but it’s got sharks in it. Mountain biking, like any skill or activity, is about progression. You need to walk before you can run.
In the context of a 100-plus kilometre mountain bike trail development, surely it wouldn’t take much to construct a relatively short, relatively flat, actually easy and low consequence trail–or series of trails–for the 5-12 year old/complete beginner demographic that begins and ends close to the Wesburn trail head.
There’s hardly a parent out there that doesn’t to some degree feel overwhelmed and burnt out. They love activities that will entertain the kids for extended periods of time and that are low-cost, low stress and accessible. The Wesburn trail head has every other ingredient required: the pump track, playground, modern toilet block, ample parking and the footy club cafe. An easy trail nearby lets the seven-year-old have a blast doing laps and getting a taste of independence while mum or dad grabs a coffee and watches the three-year-old go down the slide.
Perhaps this would also mitigate some of the ill-feeling the mountain bike park is generating in parts of the local community. At the moment you kind of already have to be a mountain biker to enjoy the trails. If ‘non mountain biking’ families and others can easily access the activity and feel a tangible benefit, perhaps they will be more tolerant of the road closures, increased traffic and other minor (or major, depending on your perspective) inconveniences of hosting such a piece of infrastructure.
